Perhaps you misunderstood what I was saying.

In 2 months we have had a total of 4500 visitors. (Most are new people discovering the site).

Only 3-4 people are returning to the site day after day.

So what we are wondering, is 3-4 people a good number of consistent readers after 2 months when we've exposed the site to 4500 people total?

Thanks for the feedback. The blog scene is easy to break into, and terribly difficult to compete in.